Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
PMRA-25Q4-01: Asset Quality - Unguaranteed Credit Deterioration
Problem loans without a government guarantee are rising while the loan book grows quickly. Credit underwriting and vertical selection have not kept pace with origination growth across small business and commercial banking. Rising losses absorb pre-provision earnings and slow capital accretion. The Board of Directors and senior management should adopt quantitative credit triggers (for example, unguaranteed nonperforming loans above 1.25% or charge-offs above 1.25%) that require a documented slowdown in affected verticals. Data Driven Capital rates the likelihood of this matter as Medium; it clears when: two quarters of falling unguaranteed nonperforming loans and charge-offs below 0.80%.
Management’s response was not obtained for this independent analysis.
PMRA-25Q4-02: Asset Quality - Concentration Limits by Industry Vertical
Losses in a single exited vertical (distillery, about 0.5% of loans) have been large relative to its size. Exposure limits are set as a share of loans rather than of capital, and did not trigger action before deterioration. Another vertical turning could produce losses out of proportion to its share of loans. The Board of Directors and senior management should set Board-approved limits for each vertical and for Commercial Banking as a percentage of total capital, with monthly reporting of migration and loss severity. Data Driven Capital rates the likelihood of this matter as Medium; it clears when: limits adopted and reported to the Board for two quarters.
Management’s response was not obtained for this independent analysis.
MANAGEMENT - 2
Management and Board oversight are satisfactory. Strategic execution and expense control are strong. The company disclosed material weaknesses in 2024-2025 covering loan review timeliness and loan participation accounting. Data Driven Capital forecasts 3 Potential MRAs this quarter.
PMRA-25Q4-03: Management - Loan Review and Risk-Rating Timeliness
A prior material weakness involved untimely identification of risk-rating downgrades. Loan review scope and frequency historically trailed portfolio risk. Problems are recognized after they become losses. The Board of Directors and senior management should expand independent loan review coverage of Commercial Banking and higher-risk verticals and test ratings against subsequent defaults. Data Driven Capital rates the likelihood of this matter as Medium; it clears when: independent testing shows risk ratings move ahead of losses under current stress.
Management’s response was not obtained for this independent analysis.
EARNINGS - 2
Earnings are satisfactory. Return on average assets (YTD, annualized) increased from 0.71 percent at year-end 2024 to 0.82 percent. The net interest margin increased from 3.36 percent at year-end 2024 to 3.40 percent. The efficiency ratio declined from 60.0 percent at year-end 2024 to 56.1 percent. Year-to-date provision expense was $96.3 million, compared with $97.1 million in the same period a year earlier, and year-to-date net income was $114.6 million, compared with $84.5 million. About 12 percent of revenue comes from gains on sale of guaranteed loans, which depend on SBA program rules and secondary-market pricing.
LIQUIDITY - 2
Liquidity is satisfactory. Total deposits of $13.8 billion increased 17.0 percent over the past twelve months. Uninsured deposits as a share of total deposits increased from 14.4 percent at year-end 2024 to 15.7 percent. Brokered deposits as a share of total deposits declined from 30.3 percent at year-end 2024 to 29.3 percent. Loans as a share of deposits increased from 89.5 percent at year-end 2024 to 89.6 percent. Deposits are gathered nationally through digital channels; brokered deposits, likely including listing-service deposits, are about 28-29 percent of total deposits.