Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Report of Examination
34997

DATA DRIVEN CAPITAL

REPORT OF EXAMINATION

OCC national bank format

InstitutionBayFirst National Bank
LocationSt. Petersburg, Florida
Certificate Number34997
CharterNational bank
RegulatorsOCC
Holding CompanyBayFirst Financial Corp. (Nasdaq: BAFN)
Analyst-in-ChargeData Driven Capital
Examination As Of DateMarch 31, 2026
Report DateNovember 15, 2026
Primary Data SourceFDIC call report, bank level

All dollar amounts are reported in thousands unless otherwise indicated.

NOTICE. This report follows the format of an OCC Report of Examination but is an independent analysis by Data Driven Capital. It is not issued by, affiliated with, or endorsed by the FDIC, the OCC or any other regulator, and it contains no confidential supervisory information. Ratings and Potential Matters Requiring Attention are Data Driven Capital’s indicative forecast from public data; actual supervisory ratings are confidential. Forecast likelihoods are analyst judgment applied to the figures shown and have not yet been validated against historical outcomes.

 
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Table of Contents
34997

All dollar amounts are reported in thousands, unless otherwise indicated.

Matters Requiring Attention1
Examination Conclusions and Comments2
Violations of Laws and Regulations6
Examination Data and Ratios7
Capital Calculations8
Items Subject to Adverse Classification9
Concentrations10
Analysis of Earnings11
Liquidity and Funds Management12
Signature of Directors13
Analyst Confidential Section14
 
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Matters Requiring Attention
34997

The Potential Matters Requiring Attention (Potential MRAs) below are listed in priority order. Each is Data Driven Capital’s forecast of a matter examiners are likely to require the Board and senior management to remediate at the next examination. For additional details, refer to the Examination Conclusions and Comments section of this report.

Management responses were not obtained for this independent analysis.

MRA NumberRisk CategorySummary
PMRA-26Q1-01
Likelihood: High
Lending Credit Risk Management and Asset Resolution: The Board should complete the asset resolution plan, re-grade the remaining portfolio, and report problem-loan resolution to the Board monthly.
PMRA-26Q1-02
Likelihood: High
Earnings Earnings and Strategic Plan: The Board should adopt a Board-approved strategic and profit plan with quarterly milestones and report variance to the Board.
PMRA-26Q1-03
Likelihood: High
Capital Capital Adequacy: The Board should adopt a capital plan that keeps total risk-based capital above 12% through the turnaround, stress-tested against further losses.
PMRA-26Q1-04
Likelihood: Medium
Management Financial Reporting and Internal Controls: The Board should remediate controls over nonaccrual and provisioning, obtain an independent review, and refile affected regulatory reports.
1
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Examination Conclusions and Comments
34997

CAMELS Ratings (Uniform Financial Institutions Rating System)

Current ReportPrior Report
Examination As Of Date03/31/202612/31/2025
Composite Rating33
Component Ratings:
Capital33
Asset Quality33
Management33
Earnings44
Liquidity33
Sensitivity to Market Risk22
Information Technology——
Compliance——
Community Reinvestment Act——

Ratings are Data Driven Capital indicative ratings. Information Technology, Compliance and Community Reinvestment Act ratings are not assessed from public data.

OVERALL CONDITION AND RISK PROFILE SUMMARY

Overall condition is less than satisfactory. Losses continued and total risk-based capital fell to 9.41 percent. An $80 million capital raise and a new chief executive were announced after quarter-end. Over the twelve months ended March 31, 2026, total assets declined 7.8 percent, gross loans declined 14.5 percent and deposits declined 3.7 percent.

Risk Assessment System

Risk CategoryQuantity of Risk Quality of Risk ManagementAggregate RiskDirection of Risk
CreditHighWeakHighStable
Interest rateModerateSatisfactoryModerateStable
LiquidityHighInsufficientHighIncreasing
PriceModerateSatisfactoryModerateStable
OperationalModerateInsufficientModerateStable
ComplianceModerateNot assessedModerateStable
StrategicHighInsufficientHighStable

The OCC assesses seven risk categories; reputation risk was removed from OCC supervision in 2025.

CAPITAL - 3

The institution's capital position is less than satisfactory and not commensurate with its risk profile. As of March 31, 2026, the leverage and total risk-based capital (TRBC) ratios were 6.20 percent and 9.41 percent, respectively. The TRBC ratio was below the 10 percent well-capitalized threshold, placing the bank in the adequately capitalized category under Prompt Corrective Action. The TRBC ratio declined from 9.75 percent at year-end 2025 to 9.41 percent, compared with 11.73 percent a year earlier. The leverage ratio increased from 6.18 percent at year-end 2025 to 6.20 percent, compared with 8.56 percent a year earlier. Over the past twelve months, total assets declined 7.8 percent while Tier 1 capital declined 31.7 percent, so capital lagged balance-sheet growth. Capital adequacy depends on the $80 million private placement completed in 2026; before it, total risk-based capital was below the well-capitalized level.

2
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Examination Conclusions and Comments
34997

PMRA-26Q1-03: Capital - Capital Adequacy

Concern. Total risk-based capital fell below the 10% well-capitalized level before the 2026 capital raise.

Root cause. Losses exceeded earnings capacity.

Consequence. Below well-capitalized, the bank faces brokered deposit restrictions and limited flexibility.

Corrective action. Adopt a capital plan that keeps total risk-based capital above 12% through the turnaround, stress-tested against further losses.

Commitment. Not obtained for this independent analysis.

Data Driven Capital rates the likelihood of this matter as High. It clears when: capital plan adopted and ratios held above target for two quarters.

ASSET QUALITY - 3

Asset quality has deteriorated and is less than satisfactory. Noncurrent loans declined from 2.69 percent at year-end 2025 to 2.47 percent, compared with 2.46 percent a year earlier. Annualized net charge-offs increased from 1.78 percent at year-end 2025 to 2.00 percent, compared with 1.23 percent a year earlier. The allowance for credit losses as a percentage of loans declined from 2.29 percent at year-end 2025 to 2.22 percent, compared with 1.52 percent a year earlier. Gross loans decreased 3.5 percent since year-end 2025 with 14.5 percent decline over the past twelve months. Commercial real estate (construction, multifamily and non-owner-occupied) represents 151 percent of total capital, up from 132 percent a year earlier, and commercial and industrial loans are 24 percent of loans. Losses are concentrated in unguaranteed small-balance SBA 7(a) loans originated before the bank exited that business.

PMRA-26Q1-01: Asset Quality - Credit Risk Management and Asset Resolution

Concern. Net charge-offs have run 1.5-2.0% annualized and nonperforming loans remain elevated.

Root cause. Unguaranteed small-balance SBA 7(a) loans were originated at a pace and standard that produced high default rates.

Consequence. Continued losses would consume the new capital.

Corrective action. Complete the asset resolution plan, re-grade the remaining portfolio, and report problem-loan resolution to the Board monthly.

Commitment. Not obtained for this independent analysis.

Data Driven Capital rates the likelihood of this matter as High. It clears when: charge-offs below 1.0% and nonperforming loans below 1.0% for two quarters.

MANAGEMENT - 3

Management and Board oversight need improvement. The bank exited SBA 7(a) lending in Q4 2025, changed chief executives in 2026, and is restating 2024, 2025 and Q1 2026 financial statements. After quarter-end the company announced an $80 million convertible preferred private placement and named Alfred Rogers chief executive. Data Driven Capital forecasts 4 Potential MRAs this quarter, compared with 4 in Q4 2025.

3
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Examination Conclusions and Comments
34997

PMRA-26Q1-04: Management - Financial Reporting and Internal Controls

Concern. Prior financial statements are being restated for understated provision expense and overstated interest income.

Root cause. Controls over nonaccrual status, deferred costs and provisioning did not operate effectively.

Consequence. Regulatory reports and capital ratios may have been misstated.

Corrective action. Remediate controls over nonaccrual and provisioning, obtain an independent review, and refile affected regulatory reports.

Commitment. Not obtained for this independent analysis.

Data Driven Capital rates the likelihood of this matter as Medium. It clears when: restated periods filed and controls tested effective.

EARNINGS - 4

Earnings are deficient. Return on average assets (YTD, annualized) declined from -1.78 percent at year-end 2025 to -1.84 percent, compared with -0.05 percent a year earlier. The net interest margin declined from 3.84 percent at year-end 2025 to 3.41 percent, compared with 3.81 percent a year earlier. The efficiency ratio increased from 109.0 percent at year-end 2025 to 141.1 percent, compared with 79.0 percent a year earlier. Year-to-date provision expense was $3.4 million, compared with $4.4 million in the same period a year earlier, and year-to-date net income was $-5.7 million, compared with $-0.2 million. The bank has reported losses in every quarter of this review period.

PMRA-26Q1-02: Earnings - Earnings and Strategic Plan

Concern. The bank has lost money in every quarter of the review period.

Root cause. The SBA 7(a) business that drove revenue also drove losses; the community bank strategy is new.

Consequence. Without sustained earnings, capital will erode again.

Corrective action. Adopt a Board-approved strategic and profit plan with quarterly milestones and report variance to the Board.

Commitment. Not obtained for this independent analysis.

Data Driven Capital rates the likelihood of this matter as High. It clears when: two consecutive profitable quarters under the new plan.

LIQUIDITY - 3

Liquidity is less than satisfactory. Total deposits of $1.1 billion decreased 8.3 percent since year-end 2025 with 3.7 percent decline over the past twelve months. Uninsured deposits as a share of total deposits increased from 14.9 percent at year-end 2025 to 17.4 percent, compared with 18.6 percent a year earlier. Brokered deposits as a share of total deposits increased from 16.5 percent at year-end 2025 to 16.9 percent, compared with 10.0 percent a year earlier. Loans as a share of deposits increased from 81.2 percent at year-end 2025 to 85.4 percent, compared with 96.1 percent a year earlier. Brokered deposits are about 16-17 percent of deposits. A bank below well-capitalized generally needs an FDIC waiver to accept or roll over brokered deposits.

SENSITIVITY TO MARKET RISK - 2

Sensitivity to market risk is satisfactory. The securities portfolio is 3 percent of total assets, compared with 3 percent a year earlier. Fair-value loans and a portfolio of purchased guaranteed USDA loans add price and prepayment exposure.

4
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Examination Conclusions and Comments
34997

SCOPE AND LIMITATIONS

This analysis relies on public data only. No loan files, management interviews, audit reports or confidential supervisory information were available. Anti-Money Laundering/Countering the Financing of Terrorism, Information Technology, Consumer Compliance and Community Reinvestment Act programs were not assessed.

DIRECTORATE RESPONSIBILITY

In a regulatory report, each director reviews the report and signs the Signature of Directors page. For this independent analysis, that page records Data Driven Capital’s review sign-off.

5
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Violations of Laws and Regulations
34997

The violations below, when identified, are listed in priority order and require remedial action by the Board and senior management. The Board is reminded of their responsibility to ensure management appropriately addresses all violations within this report.

VIOLATIONS OF LAWS AND REGULATIONS

Apparent Violations

No apparent violations were identified from public information.

Scope of Review

Loan-level compliance (legal lending limits under 12 CFR 32, Regulation O, SBA eligibility and AML/CFT) requires file review and was not tested.

6
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Examination Data and Ratios
34997
RatioQ1 2025
(year-ago)
Q4 2025
(prior year-end)
Q4 2025Q1 2026Change vs. year-endChange vs. year-ago
Total assets$1.29B$1.30B$1.30B$1.19B−8.1%−7.8%
Gross loans$1.08B$961.4M$961.4M$927.6M−3.5%−14.5%
Total deposits$1.13B$1.18B$1.18B$1.09B−8.3%−3.7%
Noncurrent loans / loans2.46%2.69%2.69%2.47%−0.22 pp+0.00 pp
Net charge-offs / loans (annualized)1.23%1.78%1.78%2.00%+0.22 pp+0.77 pp
Allowance / loans1.52%2.29%2.29%2.22%−0.06 pp+0.70 pp
Return on assets-0.05%-1.78%-1.78%-1.84%−0.06 pp−1.78 pp
Return on equity-0.60%-21.85%-21.85%-26.20%−4.35 pp−25.60 pp
Net interest margin3.81%3.84%3.84%3.41%−0.44 pp−0.40 pp
Efficiency ratio79.0%109.0%109.0%141.1%+32.1 pp+62.1 pp
CET1 / risk-weighted assets10.47%8.49%8.49%8.14%−0.35 pp−2.33 pp
Total capital / risk-weighted assets11.73%9.75%9.75%9.41%−0.35 pp−2.32 pp
Tier 1 leverage8.56%6.18%6.18%6.20%+0.02 pp−2.36 pp
CRE / total capital132%150%150%151%+1 pp+19 pp
Construction / total capital38%50%50%43%−8 pp+4 pp
Brokered deposits / deposits10.0%16.5%16.5%16.9%+0.4 pp+7.0 pp
Uninsured deposits / deposits18.6%14.9%14.9%17.4%+2.5 pp−1.2 pp
Loans / deposits96.1%81.2%81.2%85.4%+4.2 pp−10.7 pp

Return ratios from call reports are year-to-date, annualized; year-end figures are full-year.

7
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Capital Calculations
34997
ItemAmount ($000)
Tier 1 capital74,691
Tier 2 capital11,585
Total risk-based capital86,276
Risk-weighted assets917,026
RatioActualMinimumWell capitalized
CET1 / RWA8.14%4.50%6.50%
Tier 1 / RWA8.14%6.00%8.00%
Total capital / RWA9.41%8.00%10.00%
Tier 1 leverage6.20%4.00%5.00%
8
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Items Subject to Adverse Classification
34997

Examiner classifications (substandard, doubtful, loss) are confidential. This schedule shows the public problem-asset indicators examiners start from, plus any classifications the company has disclosed.

IndicatorAmount ($000) / ratio
Loans 30–89 days past due22,391
Loans 90+ days past due, still accruing3,172
Nonaccrual loans19,717
Other real estate owned400
Nonaccrual + OREO / (Tier 1 + allowance)21.1%
9
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Concentrations
34997
ConcentrationLevelGuidance level
Construction / total capital43%100%
CRE (construction, multifamily, non-owner-occupied) / total capital151%300%
Commercial & industrial / gross loans23.6%—

Guidance levels are from the 2006 interagency guidance on CRE concentrations; exceeding them calls for heightened risk management, not a prohibition.

10
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Analysis of Earnings
34997
Year to dateQ1 2026 YTD ($000)Q1 2025 YTD ($000)Change
Interest income17,42920,685−15.7%
Interest expense7,8939,582−17.6%
Net interest income9,53611,103−14.1%
Noninterest income8508,723−90.3%
Noninterest expense14,65415,659−6.4%
Provision for credit losses3,4064,401−22.6%
Net income(5,708)(176)−3143.2%

Call report income figures are year-to-date. The comparison column is the same period one year earlier.

11
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Liquidity and Funds Management
34997
ItemAmount ($000) / ratio
Total deposits1,086,271
Noninterest-bearing deposits111,878
Brokered deposits / deposits16.9%
Uninsured deposits / deposits17.4%
Cash and balances due134,465
Securities31,020
Loans / deposits85.4%
12
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Signature of Directors
34997

Each director signs this page to acknowledge review of the report. For this independent analysis, the page records Data Driven Capital’s review.

Name and TitleSignatureDate
Analyst-in-Charge, Data Driven Capital
Reviewing Analyst, Data Driven Capital
Approved for Distribution, Data Driven Capital
13
Data Driven Capital · Independent analysis from public data · Not a regulatory report
Analyst Confidential Section
34997

WATCH ITEMS

  • None this quarter.

QUESTIONS FOR MANAGEMENT

  1. Were any brokered deposits accepted or rolled over while total risk-based capital was below 10%, and was a waiver obtained?
  2. Which regulatory reports will be amended as a result of the restatement?
  3. What losses remain in the unguaranteed SBA 7(a) portfolio after the asset resolution plan?
  4. What are the quarterly milestones of the profit plan under the new chief executive?

SOURCES

14